top of page

The Anglo-Saxon Christian Kingdom - Were the Anglo Saxons Orthodox?

Being in the Western hemisphere England seems several stages removed from the ancient Orthodox faith, but with the exhibition of the Bayeux Tapestry at the British Museum one cannot help wondering what was lost in the mists of time.

The Anglo-Saxons

Certainly there are key coincidences - the Great Schism occurred only twelve years before the Norman Conquest. The Normans had the key and unusual backing of the Pope. The Anglo Saxon noblemen fled not to Rome, but to Orthodox Constantinople. There, it is believed, they joined the Byzantine Emperor’s famous Varangian Guard. These circumstances seem to indicate a continuing connection to Eastern Orthodoxy.


It must be remembered that the West did not abruptly rupture entirely with Orthodoxy at the Great Schism in 1054. Much Orthodox practice and an Orthodox phronema most likely persisted. Even that arch Roman-Catholic Saint, Francis of Assisi was inspired in his vocation by a very Byzantine style icon, the crucifix of San Damiano in 1205 in Italy. The continuing links can be seen in the way the earlier Medieval iconography still has what is now known as an “Eastern” or “Byzantine” style. It is therefore not unreasonable to assume that in the North Western island of the Anglo Saxon kingdom Orthodox practice and theology would have lasted unaffected by changes in the rest of Western Europe.


Indeed a similar and earlier pattern is evidenced in the Venerable Bede’s work of the persistence of old and irregular practices in Britain when the then-pagan Anglo Saxons conquered the post-Roman Christian society in Britain. Only at the Synod of Whitby in 664 AD when the newly converted Anglo Saxon king, Oswu, had to choose between the indigenous Celtic Christianity of his British wife, left behind to become part of the local culture by the Romans, and standard Orthodox-Catholic Christianity, were local and idiosyncratic customs laid to rest in the Seventh Century. England adopted the continental date of Easter and the Roman custom of the type of tonsure for their monastics. It is therefore not unreasonable to assume that likewise, at a later date, Anglo Saxon England had fallen out of step with the Catholic continent. This is evidenced by the Norman conquerors regularising worship in this land after the Conquest, bringing it into line with the Catholic continent under the Papacy. Perhaps some of these customs were remaining Orthodox rites that had been abandoned by the West?

In any event the Anglo Saxon Kingdom of England and its many saints belong to the history of both Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox Churches. It was a pre-Schism Kingdom and it is highly possible the effects of the Schism with the Orthodox East had not crossed the English Channel. The Anglo Saxon Christian Kingdom came to an end at almost the same time as the unity of Eastern and Western Churches.


What is also telling is that the Anglo Saxon nobility clearly felt more affinity with Constantinople than Rome. For they chose to seek refuge not in Rome but at Byzantium, becoming members of the Orthodox Emperor’s famous Varangian Guard, made up of Nordic and Germanic warriors loyal only to the Emperor.

Some say that tragically for the Anglo Saxon elite they would meet their end in the Battle of Dyrrhachium against Normans led by Robert Guiscard who were invading Byzantine Sicily. Vengeance against the invaders of their homeland turned into their own annihilation for the Anglo Saxons. Others claim the Anglo Saxons settled near the Black Sea under Byzantine protection, founding a new English kingdom in lands that would later be part of the Russian Empire. Whatever the truth, history and myth continue to link the Anglo Saxons to the Orthodox East.

In any event, as a Kingdom that existed, bar twelve years, pre-Schism, the Orthodox can certainly claim the Anglo Saxon and the British saints before them found in Bede’s History English Church and People for their own. They were saints of the same Church.

Names such as the holy king, Saint Oswald, or the famous Saint Cuthbert of Lindisfarne, and many, many more, were all Orthodox and in that the Church had not yet fallen into Schism this fact remains beyond argument. The Anglo Saxon Christian Kingdom of Athelstan, Alfred the Great and Edward the Confessor can be regarded as either Orthodox or Roman Catholic. Both traditions have a legitimate claim. The Anglo Saxons for most of their history were in communion with Rome and Constantinople.


The argument runs from the Orthodox side that English remoteness meant it had not adopted Papist innovations and remained Orthodox in practice and ethos as well as being part of the pre-Schism world. This seems to ring true. These islands have always harboured their own particular claim to ancient Christianity. From Joseph of Arimathea and Glastonbury to the Celitic monks keeping the sacred flame of Christianity alive as the Roman Empire collapsed, the roots of Christianity are deep in the British Isles.

Hidden under the layers of utilitarian and secular modernity when we stumble across ancient churches in tiny villages we rediscover that old sacredness of this island, the reality that Christ has been worshipped here from time immemorial.

We also detect a difference in tone in the Christianity of the Normans, militaristic, feudal, building their churches not in wood but stone. In theology, with Anselm’s satisfaction theory of salvation a distinctive and more legalistic understanding of the meaning of the Crucifixion was developed. Anselm was Archbishop of Canterbury in Norman England from 1093 to 1109.

Linking his satisfaction theory of salvation to the Norman feudal system, Anselm depicted God the Father as a feudal lord to whom we men owed an infinite debt of honour to the infinite God. God as the feudal lord has seen his honour offended by our sin. We are unable to atone for this dishonour to God. Therefore God’s Son, the second Person of the Trinity, must satisfy the debt and restore the Father’s honour.

This explanation of salvation is somewhat reductive in comparison to Orthodox holistic therapeutic ideas of the crucifixion as a victory and as ultimately bringing about theosis for men. One can surely say that Anselm’s theory of atonement was deeply influenced by secular feudal ideas that were primarily legalistic. This contrast is touched upon by the Greek theologian Christos Yannaras, who wrote on this topic:

“The God of the Church as known and proclaimed by Orthodox experience and tradition has never had anything to do with the God of the Roman juridical tradition, the God of Anselm and Abelard; He has never been thought of as a vengeful God, who rules by fear meting out punishments and torment for men.”

Yannaras, Christos, The God of Orthodoxy meets the Deity of the West.

In some sense we are aware of something lost and buried in the depths of England’s mysterious past. In contrast to the legalism of Roman Catholicism and the brute power of feudalism, there is something we lost long ago. From stories of the Grail, Joseph of Armimathea, forgotten British and Anglo-Saxon saints, even in the very fields and woods of the countryside we sense something that was here before. People nowadays, creatures of modernity, seek paganism that can never be recovered or modern New Age ideas of nature - the sort of temptations the likes of Seraphim Rose warned us about. By contrast, these islands have a thread of Christian faith going back into forgotten times of myth. The Monarchy itself sustains its legitimacy on the ancient roots of the Christian faith. Arthur was retold by the medieval poets as the apogee of Christian kingliness. Alfred the Great defended us from the Vikings and was instrumental in their conversion as they settled here.

We know there is a Greek Orthodox Church, a Russian Orthodox Church, a Romanian and so on - Orthodoxy is always rooted in the local culture. Was the end of Anglo Saxon England a breach and severance with an English Orthodox Church? Perhaps that is the true Grail to be found, hidden in the spiritual depths of our ancient history.

Matthew Groves

bottom of page